The One That Got Away (2022)

Episode Overview

Heartbroken by her previous Arrivals, Allyssa turns to The Portal for one final opportunity to meet someone special. To her surprise, The Portal reconnects her with an old flame. Meanwhile, Kasey embarks on an adorably cheesy date. Nigel decides to deepen his connection with one of his initial Arrivals. Jeff faces the toughest decision of his journey, and his contentious choice results in an emotional fallout, leaving many in tears.