Nightmare Next Door (2011)

Episode Overview

In the small town of Portage, Indiana, the community is shaken when 8-year-old Sarah Paulsen is tragically assaulted and killed in 1995. As fear grips the residents, accusations fly as they speculate about whether her murderer is a familiar face from their neighborhood or an unfamiliar outsider. The police sift through countless leads in their quest to uncover the truth behind this horrific crime.